Bernie Sanders champions universal healthcare as Republicans' planned Obamacare repeal implodes

Left-winger finds a receptive audience in San Francisco

Jeremy B. White
San Francisco
Friday 22 September 2017 22:47 BST
Bernie Sanders trumpeted his universal healthcare plan as an alternative to a faltering Republican bill in San Francisco, California on September 22, 2017
Bernie Sanders trumpeted his universal healthcare plan as an alternative to a faltering Republican bill in San Francisco, California on September 22, 2017 (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Bernie Sanders touted his universal healthcare proposal as an alternative to a collapsing Republican repeal effort on Friday, offering a preview of how divergent healthcare visions could dominate future elections.

Speaking in San Francisco before a sympathetic crowd of unionized nurses gathered for a California Nurses Association summit, the independent Senator lambasted Republics for pushing “another piece of horrific legislation” as they seek once again to unravel Barack Obama’s signature healthcare law.

The Republican push was teetering on the verge of failure Friday after Sen John McCain announced he would not support the latest bill, a move that Mr Sanders praised by saying “John McCain has a conscience, and I wish very much that the rest of the Republican leadership had that conscience as well”.

“How cruel, how immoral it is to say to those million of Americans, ‘We are going to take away that health insurance that keeps you alive”, Mr Sanders said. “We are going to defeat another proposal which is even worse than the other ones”, he added, saying Republicans who back the bill “will pay a very heavy political price”.

As Republican efforts on healthcare have faltered, Mr Sanders has steadily attracted support for a bill that seeks to extend healthcare to all Americans through Medicare, a government insurance program. He spoke in front of a large poster blaring “It’s Time to Act! Medicare for All!” and a crowd hoisting signs with the same message.

“In terms of healthcare, maintaining the status quo is just not good enough”, Mr Sanders said. “The function of a rational healthcare system is not to make billions in profit for the drug companies and the insurance companies”, he added. “The function of a rational healthcare system is to provide healthcare to all people when they need it”.

Should Mr Sanders again seek the presidency, his healthcare agenda would likely be a centerpiece of his campaign. His appearance in California - following a foreign policy-oriented speech in Missouri earlier this week - has fueled speculation that Mr Sanders is laying the groundwork for another shot at the White House. Ahead of his speech, California Nurses Association Executive Director RoseAnn DeMoro led the crowd in chants of “Run Bernie, Run”!

As Mr Sanders has ascended to national prominence, California has wrestled with the same issues he champions. The Democrat-dominated state's failures to enact policies at the top of Mr Sanders’ agenda underscores the difficulty Mr Sanders faces in advancing his populist platform.

Bernie Sanders: "The Republican party is now a right-wing extremist party"

Last year, Mr Sanders threw his weight behind a California ballot initiative that sought to hold down drug prices. The proposal failed in the face of a multi-million dollar pharmaceutical industry onslaught and questions about whether the measure would work as intended.

Earlier this year, the pursuit of another coveted goal of Sanders-aligned liberals - universal healthcare - stalled in the state legislature. Leadership shelved a bill that would have instituted a single-payer healthcare system in California, noting a lack of funding made the costly proposal unlikely to work.

The decision laid bare divisions within deep-blue California’s political landscape. The California Nurses Association, the state’s leading institutional backer of Mr Sanders’ presidential bid, savaged Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon for halting the bill and drew condemnation for tweeting an image of a knife labeled “Rendon” plunged into the back of a bear on California’s state flag.

Mr Rendon said he received death threats. Ms DeMoro went on the attack again before Mr Sanders spoke, drawing boos as she slammed Mr Rendon for using “czar-like powers to hold up the Assembly from having a vote”.

On the national level, Mr Sanders has faced skepticism over his bill to cover all Americans. As with the California bill, critics say Mr Sanders has not devised a way to pay for his proposal.

But California politicians with national profiles have increasingly embraced the idea. Lt Gov Gavin Newsom, who is running for governor, publicly proclaimed his support for single-payer healthcare while speaking to the nurses group on Friday.

Democratic Sen. Kamala Harris, whose name appears on most lists of potential 2020 presidential candidates, has already signed on as a coauthor.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in