Earps strongly opposed Hannah Hampton's recall and selection, telling Wiegman that Hampton's 'bad behaviour is being rewarded'.
She claimed Hampton's conduct during Euro 2022 was 'disruptive and unreliable', potentially jeopardising team harmony and training.
Wiegman informed Earps in April 2025 that she was no longer the first-choice goalkeeper, which led to Earps' decision to retire due to feeling unsupported and a loss of trust.
Earps initially reconsidered her retirement but finalised it after Wiegman admitted not watching her recent club match, reinforcing Earps' perception of Wiegman's lack of commitment.